Somewhere between the hours of 2 and 3 in the afternoon, a bell rings and school is out.
Now what?
94% of American parents feel that there needs to be some type of organized after-school activity for their children to attend and learn from everyday.[1] Whether the reason for this significant statistic is that these parents are part of the 28 million American parents that work outside the home in the US,[2] or that they just want to provide their child with further educational and social enrichment, the bottom line is that after-school programming is necessary.
As more schools and communities respond to this fact, and as more and more programs become available in our schools, the question is no longer “Do we need after-school programs,” the question now becomes “How do I choose the right programs for my children?” In other words, what works?
The need and interest in after-school programming is good news. A recent study known as the Promising Afterschool Programs study, which examined 2,914 students in 8 states over the course of 3 years, shows that after two years, students who regularly attend high-quality and engaging after-school programs are academically far ahead of peers who spend more out-of-school time in unsupervised activities.
This is a summary of the study as reported by Education Week in November of 2007:
“…Researchers divided students into three groups: a ‘program only’ group of students who attended their afterschool program two or three times a week and did nothing else outside the school; a ‘program plus’ group who visited the afterschool programs two or three times a week and also took part in sports, church programs, music lessons, or other extracurricular activities; and a ‘low supervision’ group who dropped in on a mix of afterschool activities from one to three days a week.
The researchers found, over the course of the three-year project, that the more engaged students were in supervised afterschool activities, the better they did on a range of academic, social, and behavioral outcomes. For instance, 3rd and 4th graders in the ‘program plus’ group tallied gains on standardized mathematics tests that were 20 percentile points higher than those of children who rarely went. The frequent attendees also made more progress in developing sound work habits, task persistence, and better social skills, and in reducing negative behaviors such as skipping school or fighting.”
One of the important factors to take away from this study is that the achieved conclusions were the effects of participating in “high-quality” programming. This study specifically examined 35 programs, selected for their record of success and considered by the researchers to be “high-quality.” In order to determine whether a program fit the mold, the study used a rating system which assessed programs based on:
- Evidence of supportive relationships between staff and child participants
- Evidence of rich and varied academic support, recreation, arts opportunities, and other enrichment activities
- Students typically were highly engaged with one another and with program activities
- Group leaders structured activities to maximize learning and positive relationships.
- Adults facilitated activities without imposing controls that limited student learning opportunities.
- Disruptive or chaotic behavior was rarely observed; when behavioral disruptions occurred, leaders managed them calmly and constructively
Based on this study, it’s easy to understand that quality makes the difference in attaining the benefits of after-school programming. Fortunately, this realization has spawned the development of comprehensive tools to help administrators determine just that level of quality. Administrators can now use surveys, such as the ones highlighted in Using Assessment Tools to Evaluate Afterschool Programs, published by American Youth Policy Forum to determine which programs best compliment their curriculum and offer the most overall value to their students.
For parents, choosing an afterschool program is founded on a more personal basis. To chose afterschool activities for our children we need to consider their age, learning styles, interests and developmental needs. Parents should consider that:
- Children need a balance of pro-social and physical activities. As visual, verbal and social learners, they need a variety of opportunities to fully develop. You don’t want to overload your child, so chose the activities that have the highest ratio of fun, education and developmental value.
- After school activities are also a great resource to help your child develop in new ways. Look for a balance between activities you know they enjoy already and activities that will help them develop new skills and abilities.
- Look for programs that support and enhance their classroom education without duplicating the experience. Chose programs that enforce the academic goals but approach the learning from a fresh and engaging angle. For example, music and art help children to consider a pattern, think ahead and find a new way to solve a problem.
- Who’s teaching your child? A teacher must be able to effectively manage a group of children, know how to teach and teach well, and most of all influence your child in a positive way. Your child should come home feeling great about what they’ve done and about themselves.
The key to a beneficial experience in any afterschool activity is to make a reasonable time commitment to that activity. It is better to master a few skills, and to acquire the pride and confidence of gaining that skill, than is to dabble in all skills and therefore excel in none.
Once you and your child have chosen an afterschool activity, have them commit to that activity for the duration of the school year, or a reasonable time frame for that particular activity. This teaches your child to be accountable for their decisions and complete their goals; and best of all allows your child to maximize the full educational benefits of the program.
The fact is; afterschool programs are necessary, they enhance our children’s learning and experiences, and that after-school programs will continue to be an important element in our children’s lives. By taking the time to evaluate and to choose the right program for you – and the right program for your child, you can truly take advantage of the valuable and the multitude of benefits that afterschool programs have to offer.
Resources:
For more articles, and studies on the benefits of after-school programming visit: www.afterschoolalliance.org , and www.middleweb.com/afterschool.html
For administrators looking for information on evaluating their after-school programming see, Using Assessment Tools to Evaluate Afterschool Programs, published by American Youth Policy Forum and Measuring Youth Program Quality: A Guide to Assessment Tools published by The Forum for Youth Investment.